top of page

How to Read a Hospice's CMS Quality Ratings (HCI Score & CAHPS Stars)

Sep 2
5 min read

Updated: Nov 8

The short answer: Medicare-certified hospices carry two separate CMS quality scores. The Hospice Care Index (HCI) is a claims-based score from 0 to 10, built from ten indicators drawn from billing and visit records, and almost every hospice has one. The CAHPS Hospice Survey Star Rating is a 1-to-5 star score built from a family caregiver survey, but it's only published for hospices with 75 or more completed surveys, so many smaller hospices show no star rating at all.¹,⁴ They measure different things and should be read together, not as substitutes for each other.


What Is the Hospice Care Index (HCI)?

The HCI is a claims-based composite hospice quality measure. CMS builds it from ten specific indicators drawn from the billing and visit records every Medicare-certified hospice already files, scored from 0 to 10.¹ Because it comes from data hospices already submit rather than a survey, nearly every Medicare-certified hospice has an HCI score.


The ten indicators are:

  1. Continuous home care or general inpatient care provided

  2. Gaps in skilled nursing visits

  3. Early live discharges

  4. Late live discharges

  5. Burdensome transitions, type 1 (live discharge followed by hospitalization and readmission)

  6. Burdensome transitions, type 2 (live discharge followed by hospitalization and in-hospital death)

  7. Per-beneficiary Medicare spending

  8. Skilled nursing minutes per routine home care day

  9. Skilled nursing minutes on weekends

  10. Visits near death


What Is the CAHPS Hospice Survey Star Rating?

The CAHPS Hospice Survey Star Rating is a 1-to-5 star score built from a standardized survey mailed to the families of patients who died under a hospice's care.² Its publicly reported results cover five areas of experience, scored using "top-box" methodology, meaning it reflects the share of respondents who gave the single most positive answer, not a plain average.³ A sixth area, training families to care for the patient, was removed from public reporting starting with CMS's May 2026 refresh.⁷

  • Communication

  • Timeliness of help

  • Respectful, dignified care

  • Emotional and spiritual support

  • Pain and symptom management


Why Does a Hospice Sometimes Show No CAHPS Star Rating?

Good to know: A missing star rating means a hospice hasn't collected enough completed surveys yet. It does not mean the hospice provides poor care. CMS only publishes a star rating for hospices with 75 or more completed surveys over the reporting period. Hospices below that threshold still get their underlying measure scores published, which requires only 30 completed surveys, but they don't get a rolled-up star rating.⁴


This is common, not rare. A 2025 analysis reported by Hospice News found the number of Medicare-certified hospices without any star rating grew from 3,912 in August 2022 to 5,086 in August 2024. Hospices without a rating skewed smaller and more often for-profit.⁵ Nearly two-thirds of all Medicare hospices had no star rating when the system launched in 2022.⁵ In CMS’s current data, about two-thirds of Medicare-certified hospices have no star rating, consistent with that national pattern. The share of rated hospices earning five stars also varies widely from state to state. See how your state compares on our hospice quality by state page.


How Should I Read HCI and CAHPS Together?

Treat them as two different lenses on the same hospice, not one combined verdict.

  • Strong on both: A consistent picture. The hospice's own records and the families it served are telling the same story.

  • Strong HCI, no CAHPS rating: Usually just reflects survey volume, not a quality issue on its own.

  • A mismatch between the two: Worth a closer look, rather than picking whichever number looks better.


CMS does not publish an official "good" or "bad" threshold for either score. Both are comparison tools meant to support a real conversation with the hospice, not replace one.


Where Do These Hospice Quality Scores Appear on Hospice Guidebook?

Every provider profile on Hospice Guidebook pulls the HCI score and CAHPS star rating directly from CMS's public data, refreshed on CMS's own release cycle. Profiles also show individual family survey scores as separate bars. Hospice Guidebook flags standout providers with a Provider Excellence badge when a hospice's HCI score is 9.0 or higher and its CAHPS rating is either 4 stars or higher, or not yet rated due to survey volume, so a high-performing small hospice isn't penalized for not having 75 surveys yet.


Example profile: "Aaron Hospice" is a fictitious listing, used here for demonstration purposes only.

Example Hospice Guidebook provider profile showing the CAHPS star rating, the Hospice Care Index (HCI) score out of 10, and individual quality scores.

Can I Verify These Numbers Myself?

Yes. Every score on Hospice Guidebook traces back to CMS's public data, and you can look up any specific hospice directly on Medicare's own Care Compare tool.⁶ Star ratings update every other quarter, so a small gap between what you see on different sites is normal, not an error. Check the reporting date shown on the profile before assuming a discrepancy. Our data sources and methodology page explains how we use this data.


Frequently Asked Questions

What is a good HCI score for a hospice?

CMS doesn't publish an official "good" threshold. The scale runs from 0 to 10, and higher generally indicates stronger performance across the ten claims-based indicators, but it's meant for comparison between hospices rather than as a pass/fail certification.¹

What does it mean if a hospice has no CAHPS star rating?

It almost always means the hospice hasn't collected 75 completed surveys over the reporting period yet, not that its care quality is poor. This is especially common among smaller and newer hospices.⁴

How often are CMS hospice ratings updated?

CAHPS star ratings update every other quarter. HCI scores follow CMS's regular claims-based reporting cycle. Check the reporting date on any profile to see the current period.⁴

Can a hospice have a high HCI score and no CAHPS rating at the same time?

Yes, and it's common. HCI is claims-based, so almost every hospice has one. CAHPS requires 75 completed surveys to generate a star rating, which many smaller hospices haven't reached.¹,⁴

How many completed surveys does a hospice need for a CAHPS star rating?

75 or more completed surveys over the reporting period for a star rating. Hospices with at least 30 completed surveys still get their underlying measure scores published, just without a rolled-up star rating.⁴

Where can I verify a hospice's official CMS rating myself?

Directly on Medicare's Care Compare tool, the same public source Hospice Guidebook's data comes from.⁶


Ready to compare hospices near you using real CMS quality data? Search the Hospice Directory

This isn't medical or legal advice. This article explains how to read publicly reported CMS quality data. It isn't a recommendation for or against any specific hospice. Choosing a hospice is a decision to make with a physician or a family's care team, who can weigh a specific situation alongside these numbers.

Written by the Hospice Guidebook editorial team. Facts are checked against federal sources, including CMS and Medicare, before publishing. About us · How we source our data


Sources


How we write, check and correct our content is explained in our Editorial Policy.

bottom of page