top of page

Does Private Insurance Cover Hospice the Same Way as Medicare?

Sep 8
7 min read

Updated: Nov 8

health insurance card

The short answer: Most families who start researching hospice assume there's one national rulebook, the way there is for Medicare. If you or a family member have a job-based health plan or a marketplace policy instead, the honest answer is more complicated. Private insurance almost always covers hospice care in some form, but not because federal law requires it the way Medicare does. Hospice isn't one of the Affordable Care Act's ten required essential health benefits, so there's no single national standard for what a private plan must cover or how. Coverage details, limits, and even respite-care caps vary by insurer and state, and a Medicare Advantage plan hands hospice off to Original Medicare's standardized benefit rather than covering it under its own rules.


Does Private Insurance Cover Hospice the Same Way as Medicare?

Not really, even though most people with private insurance who need hospice do get it covered one way or another. Medicare runs on one federal benefit: four clearly defined levels of care, a fixed nationwide per-diem rate the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) sets once a year, and the same eligibility and payment rules no matter which state you live in or which hospice you choose.¹ A private health plan's hospice benefit, by contrast, is whatever that specific plan's Evidence of Coverage document says it is: its own network rules, its own limits, its own definitions, set by that one insurer for that one plan.


Is Hospice One of the ACA's Required Essential Health Benefits?

No. The Affordable Care Act requires non-grandfathered individual and small-group market plans to cover ten essential health benefit (EHB) categories: ambulatory patient services, emergency services, hospitalization, maternity and newborn care, mental health and substance use disorder services, prescription drugs, rehabilitative and habilitative services, laboratory services, preventive and wellness services, and pediatric services.²

Hospice care is not one of them, and it isn't named as an example under any of the ten either.² That requirement also only reaches non-grandfathered plans in the individual and small-group markets in the first place, the marketplace-style and small-employer plans, not the large-group and self-funded employer plans that cover most people with job-based insurance.³

Medicare has one hospice rulebook for the whole country. Private insurance has a different one for every insurer that offers it.

So Why Do Most Private Health Plans Cover Hospice Anyway?

Because of how EHB benchmark plans were built, not because of a hospice-specific mandate. Each state's benchmark plan was originally based on an actual commercial insurance plan that was really sold in that state, starting from 2012 or 2014 plans.⁴ A lot of those real, pre-ACA commercial products already covered hospice as a standard benefit, and that coverage simply carried forward into the state's benchmark plan alongside the ten required categories. That's why hospice shows up as a covered benefit in state benchmark plan documents like Colorado's, which explicitly lists hospice care as covered.⁵ It's a near-universal benefit in practice, just not a legally guaranteed floor the way maternity care or emergency services are.


Which Private Plans Have No Federal Requirement to Cover Hospice at All?

Two categories carry no EHB obligation whatsoever: large-group employer plans and self-funded (ERISA) employer plans, which together make up most of the job-based coverage in the country, and grandfathered plans that predate the ACA's major reforms and haven't changed enough to lose that status.³ Neither is required to include hospice, or any of the ten EHB categories, because the federal EHB rule was written to reach the individual and small-group markets specifically. In practice, hospice is such a long-standing, widely offered benefit in employer group insurance that most of these plans include it anyway. But there's no federal floor guaranteeing it the way there is for a marketplace plan's ten required categories, so what your specific plan actually promises is worth confirming directly rather than assumed.


How Does Hospice Work If You Have a Medicare Advantage Plan?

Even though a Medicare Advantage (MA) plan is sold by a private insurer, hospice has historically been "carved out" of it. When an MA enrollee elects hospice, Original Medicare, not the private MA plan, becomes financially responsible for the hospice benefit, paid at the same federal per-diem rates and under the same rules covered above, while the enrollee can keep their MA plan for care unrelated to the terminal illness.⁶ CMS tested a different approach between 2021 and 2024, a demonstration that let some MA plans manage hospice directly ("carve-in"), including a feature that let enrollees keep receiving certain other treatments for one month after electing hospice.⁶ That demonstration's hospice component ended December 31, 2024, after CMS cited declining participation and operational challenges, including difficulty getting hospices into MA networks and disappointing use of the concurrent-care option.⁷ As of early 2026, hospice remains carved out to Original Medicare for the large majority of Medicare Advantage enrollees, and proposals to bring it back under MA plans still face real opposition in Congress.⁸


What Actually Differs in the Fine Print?

This is where the lack of a single national standard shows up concretely.

  • Who sets the rules. Medicare: one federal benefit, the same nationwide, with per-diem rates CMS sets once a year.¹ Private insurance: whatever that specific plan's own Evidence of Coverage document says.

  • Respite care. Medicare: 5 consecutive days per stay, can recur throughout the whole hospice election, no lifetime cap.¹ Private insurance: varies by plan. South Dakota's benchmark plan, for example, caps it at a combined 15 inpatient and 15 outpatient days, for life.⁹

  • Network and prior authorization. Medicare: physician certification of a terminal prognosis, no separate insurer authorization step. Private insurance: can run through the insurer's normal network and prior-authorization rules, like any other covered service.

  • Medicare Advantage enrollees. Medicare: not applicable, it's Medicare's own benefit. Private insurance: hospice is carved out. Original Medicare pays and administers it, not the private MA plan.⁶

Once South Dakota's respite allowance is used up under that plan, it's gone for good, a real structural difference from Medicare's benefit, which can recur as needed throughout the whole hospice election. The specifics of network rules and prior authorization vary by carrier and plan, so a private hospice benefit can come with steps Medicare's doesn't use at all.


Do You Still Have to Give Up Curative Treatment for the Terminal Illness?

Generally, yes, under both. Electing the Medicare hospice benefit means waiving Medicare payment for services related to treating the terminal illness itself, since the hospice takes over that care, and federal guidance is explicit that non-hospice care for something unrelated to the terminal illness should be the rare exception rather than the norm once hospice starts.¹⁰ Private plans generally build in the same trade-off. Colorado's benchmark plan, for instance, states plainly that electing hospice means you won't receive additional benefits for the terminal illness itself.⁵ The specific wording differs plan to plan, but the underlying idea, that hospice replaces rather than supplements standard treatment of the terminal condition, holds across both public and private coverage.

Good to know: A plan's marketing brochure usually won't spell any of this out. The document that actually governs your hospice benefit is called your Evidence of Coverage (individual and marketplace plans) or Certificate of Coverage (many group plans). If you can't find it, your insurance card's member services number can pull it up and confirm the specifics, including any respite-day limit and whether prior authorization is required, before you need the answer in a hurry.


Man evaluating insurance coverage with his computer

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Does Medicare Advantage count as "private insurance" for hospice purposes?

    • It's sold by a private insurer, but for hospice specifically, coverage and payment shift to Original Medicare's standardized national benefit rather than the Medicare Advantage plan's own rules, so in practice it behaves like Medicare, not like a typical commercial plan, once hospice is elected.⁶

  • Do self-funded employer health plans have to cover hospice?

    • No federal law requires it. Self-funded (ERISA) and large-group employer plans fall outside the ACA's essential health benefits requirement entirely, though hospice is such a standard, long-offered benefit in commercial group insurance that most of these plans include it anyway.³

  • Is the six-month prognosis rule the same under private insurance?

    • Most private hospice benefits use the same general eligibility concept as Medicare, a prognosis of six months or less if the illness runs its normal course, since that's the standard clinical definition of hospice care industry-wide.⁵ Your own plan's specific language is what actually governs your coverage, so it's worth confirming directly.

  • What happened to the Medicare Advantage hospice carve-in program?

    • CMS ended the hospice component of its Value-Based Insurance Design demonstration on December 31, 2024, citing declining plan participation and operational difficulties. Hospice remains carved out to Original Medicare for the large majority of Medicare Advantage enrollees as of early 2026.⁷,⁸


Does This Affect How You Compare Hospices?

Not directly. Whether you're on Medicare, Medicare Advantage, or a private plan, the CMS quality data behind a hospice's CAHPS star rating and Health Care Index score comes from the same federal reporting requirements either way. Once you've confirmed what your own coverage actually pays for, comparing hospices on real quality data is the same next step no matter who's footing the bill. Our data sources and methodology page explains where those scores come from.

Ready to compare hospices near you using real CMS quality data? Search the Hospice Directory

This isn't insurance, medical, or legal advice. This article describes general patterns in how Medicare and private health insurance approach hospice coverage. It is not a substitute for your own plan's Evidence of Coverage or Summary of Benefits document. Coverage details, limits, and rules vary by insurer, employer, and state, and can change. Contact your health plan directly, or ask your hospice's admissions or financial counseling staff, to confirm exactly what your specific coverage pays for before making care decisions.

Written by the Hospice Guidebook editorial team. Facts are checked against federal sources, including CMS and Medicare, before publishing. About us · How we source our data


Sources


How we write, check and correct our content is explained in our Editorial Policy.


Photography

bottom of page